Employee Evaluation Form – template and overview
An employee evaluation form is used to review and document employee performance. It supports HR decisions and helps in establishing an employee development path.
An employee evaluation form is used to review and document employee performance. What to write in it and what not to put in the form? Let's find out!
In this article, you will learn how to create a practical and effective employee evaluation form that supports consistent performance review standards. You’ll discover what to include, which templates to use, and how to structure the evaluation process for meaningful feedback. You will also find out how employee evaluations help managers assess performance and support employee development.
What is an employee evaluation form?
When you want to evaluate your employees' performance, you need a tool to help you objectively measure employee performance. An employee evaluation form is a tool that gives you exactly what you require.
The form consists of several questions with a Likert scale, which allows one to assess how an employee performed for the given time. The document also includes open questions where employees can discuss their desire for professional development. You can evaluate employees repeatedly to get more accurate data.
Thanks to the employee evaluation form, it's easier to properly set a development path for employees. That includes additional training and planning the future company structure based on projected promotions.
Employee evaluation form importance
There are more benefits of employee evaluations. First, they allow the creation of consistent performance evaluation standards that measure employees' performance, motivation, and happiness.
This information is essential for reducing the company's turnover and building a friendly work environment. Additionally, data collected during evaluation can help prevent employee burnout and build a company culture that supports work-life balance.
Types of employee evaluation forms
There are numerous performance evaluation forms depending on the situation and given employee. The most common of them are:
- 360-degree evaluation form – includes employer reviews, self-reviews, and peer reviews to provide well-rounded performance information.
- Management by objective (MBO) – allows to discuss the progress with management and employees working together, identification of goals, and evaluation of whether the employee met their goals.
- Behaviorally anchored rating scale (BARS) – allows for measuring performance with specific behavioral examples to predetermine role standards.
When choosing an evaluation form, remember that, depending on a role, you may need to prepare several versions of the evaluation form to ensure they suit the employee. For example, there will be a different evaluation form for managers and regular employees, so there will be a different one for the IT and marketing departments.
What to include in the employee evaluation form
When preparing the employee evaluation form, you should include information to ensure the document is understandable and allows you to measure employees' performance objectively. According to the findings of a systematic review, organizations that adopt tailored evaluation templates and clearly defined evaluation criteria see stronger alignment between employee performance metrics and organizational goals. [Source: mdpi.com, 2022, The Key Strategies for Measuring Employee Performance in Companies: A Systematic Review].
- Employee data – information such as employee name, job title, ID, department, and manager.
- Job responsibilities – it's excellent to list employees' duties from their job description to cross-reference them with employee performance and their progress;
- Provide descriptions – describe the goals for the given employee based on their job responsibilities and the rating system to make sure all the forms are correctly filled out.
- Make space for open questions and comments – they will give you more specific data to dive into when comparing the form with other evaluations.
- Provide space to sign up the document – for both the employee and the person conducting the evaluation.
How to write an employee evaluation form
When preparing and conducting employee evaluations, ground rules will help you gather valuable information and be a base for assisting the employees in working better, staying motivated, and feeling good in the organization's environment. Remember to:
- Explain what the purpose of the evaluation form – to stay transparent with your employees and explain how gathered information will be helpful.
- Customize the form accordingly to each position – different responsibilities and measurements depend on the job role, which must be included.
- Be objective – use the numeric scale everywhere it's possible and avoid subjective language.
- Make space for open answers – to gather more detailed information that can help prepare the professional development plan.
- provide feedback – after evaluation, talk to employees and make sure they understand what to do to improve their job and performance.
Now that you know everything about employee evaluation forms and their benefits, you can help your employees in their professional development and increase your company’s performance.
Summary
A well-structured employee evaluation form helps standardize the performance review process and supports meaningful conversations between managers and employees. Using clear evaluation templates ensures accurate assessment, consistent documentation, and improved employee development. Strong performance management practices ultimately help organizations strengthen performance, engagement, and employee success.
Try Calamari for free to streamline your performance review workflows and stay updated with HR best practices – join our HR Newsletter.
FAQ: Employee Evaluation Form – template and overview
What is an employee evaluation form, and how does it support effective employee evaluations?
An employee evaluation form is a structured form used during the evaluation process to assess employee performance across clear evaluation criteria. These forms help managers and employees track employee progress and prepare for the next review using standardized review templates.
What should an employee evaluation form include when creating an employee evaluation form template?
A strong employee evaluation form template should include employee information, a review period, a rating scale, and detailed performance evaluation sections that reflect the employee’s performance. This ensures the review form captures meaningful data for human resources and supports consistent employee performance reviews.
What types of employee evaluation templates are available for managers conducting performance reviews?
There are many types of employee evaluation templates, including the annual performance review template, mid-year performance review template, quarterly performance review template, and 360-degree feedback form. Each evaluation template helps assess job performance and support a more effective performance management process for both managers and employees.
How do managers write an effective employee performance review using employee review templates?
To write a strong review, managers should use employee review templates that outline clear performance indicators, provide space for employee feedback, and capture measurable performance metrics. These tools help evaluate employee performance, address performance issues, and document overall performance for the next review period.
How can using employee performance review templates improve employee performance and employee retention?
Using structured employee performance review templates helps assess employees's performance fairly and promotes employee improvement through actionable goals. This consistency in performance evaluation forms boosts employee engagement, strengthens employee success, and supports long-term employee retention.
How do managers conduct performance reviews effectively with a manager evaluation form and performance evaluation forms?
To conduct performance reviews effectively, managers should rely on a manager evaluation form and structured performance appraisal tools that track performance over time. These evaluation forms provide a clear method to assess their performance, review employee experience, and ensure every employee review form supports accurate performance ratings and improvement goals.
